Stated on November 8, 2020 in a Facebook post:
Overnight, election workers “found” 140,000 mail in ballots in Wisconsin; 200,000 in Michigan and 1 million in Pennsylvania. “All for Biden. None for Trump.”
The internet is flooded with baseless claims of surprise ballots being "found" for President-elect Joe Biden in certain swing states.
One posted on Facebook Nov. 8 takes the form of a screenshot of a tweet posted Nov. 5 by Nick Adams, who calls himself "Trump’s favorite author":
"Between 3:00-4:30 A.M., they ‘found’ 140,000 mail in ballots for Biden in Wisconsin. Between 3:30-5:00 A.M., they ‘found’ 200,000 mail in ballots for Biden in Michigan. Between 2:00-4:00 A.M., they ‘found’ 1,000,000 mail in ballots in Pennsylvania. All for Biden. None for Trump."
The post was flagged as part of Facebook’s efforts to combat false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about our partnership with Facebook.)
It seems to be based on a misunderstanding of how counting mail in ballots works.
Some of the numbers are simply wrong, while others represent exaggerated versions of misinformation we have already debunked.
Let’s take it state by state.
Wisconsin
We previously debunked a Nov. 4 claim that said 112,000 ballots, all for Joe Biden, mysteriously surfaced in the middle of the night after Election Day in Wisconsin. Officials there said they didn’t know what the number could have been referencing; at the time they were still counting absentee ballots overnight.
This new post changes it up a bit, claiming instead that "140,000" ballots were found for Biden between 3 and 4:30 a.m. in the state, presumably the night after Election Day polls closed Nov. 3 and into the morning of Nov. 4.
The figure is close to the number of mail in votes that were cast for Biden in Milwaukee County overall.
There was a jump in votes for Biden on the night of Nov. 3 because a large batch of absentee ballots from the City of Milwaukee finished processing around 3:30 a.m., election officials told us.
Election officials worked through the night in Wisconsin to tally the unprecedented numbers of mail in ballots, which under state law they were not allowed to start counting until Election Day.
"A batch of about 170,000 absentee ballots is what came in from the City of Milwaukee. That’s just the final tally, and when it arrived," said Brian Rothgery, public information manager at the Milwaukee County Board of Supervisors, referencing the time cited in the post.
Biden has won 69% of the vote in the county. For comparison, Hillary Clinton won about 65% of the vote in the county in 2016.
Michigan
We couldn’t find evidence that 200,000 mail in ballots for Biden were found overnight, any night, in Michigan.
The claim appears to be an exaggerated iteration of posts that falsely said Biden received a suspicious influx of 138,339 votes in Michigan overnight following Election Day, while other candidates received none.
That claim relied on a data error that appeared on the elections map powered by Decision Desk HQ, an election data and analysis service.
The error came from the central Michigan county of Shiawassee. Caroline Wilson, the county’s clerk, told fact-checking organization AFP that she added an extra zero accidentally, reporting 153,710 votes for Biden instead of 15,371.
The difference, 138,339, was removed from Biden’s total within about 20 minutes, election officials said.
Pennsylvania
We have seen no credible reports that Pennsylvania election workers discovered 1 million mail in ballots for Biden "between 2 and 4 a.m.," or at any other time.
The claim may have originated from this Gateway Pundit story, which says that, "Democrats, in the privacy of the Philly Convention Center, without ANY GOP inspectors, added OVER ONE MILLION VOTES to Joe Biden’s totals in 2 days!"
That’s not the case. A judge ruled to let election observers watch the count in Philadelphia from closer up, but representatives from both parties have been allowed to observe the process all along. The counting is also being streamed live online.
Election officials in the state told PolitiFact there is "no truth to the claim" that any votes were mysteriously "found" for Biden there.
In Pennsylvania, both Trump and Biden gained around 1 million votes on the night of Nov. 3 and into the morning of Nov. 4, according to the FiveThirtyEight election graph, which showed that the biggest increase happened between midnight and 3 a.m.
Facebook posts are spreading a tweet that claims election workers, overnight, "found" 140,000 mail in ballots in Wisconsin, 200,000 in Michigan and 1 million in Pennsylvania, and all were for Biden.
This is inaccurate. The numbers are either wrong or exaggerated, and the post misinterprets the counting and reporting of legal mail in ballots as "found" votes.
We rate this False.
